Elijah Black is a Greenville, South Carolina native with a B.A. English from Coastal Carolina University. He is a fiction writer and also works as a freelance writer and editor. He’s worked as a Production Assistant for WYFF 4 and has been published in several publications and websites across the United States.

Full Bio →

Written by

Rachael Brennan has been working in the insurance industry since 2006 when she began working as a licensed insurance representative for 21st Century Insurance, during which time she earned her Property and Casualty license in all 50 states. After several years she expanded her insurance expertise, earning her license in Health and AD&D insurance as well. She has worked for small health in...

Full Bio →

Reviewed by Rachael Brennan
Licensed Auto Insurance Agent

UPDATED: Apr 1, 2021

Advertiser Disclosure

It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.

Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We are not affiliated with any one insurance provider and cannot guarantee quotes from any single provider.

Our insurance industry partnerships don’t influence our content. Our opinions are our own. To compare quotes from many different companies please enter your ZIP code on this page to use the free quote tool. The more quotes you compare, the more chances to save.

Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about auto insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything auto insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by auto insurance experts.

New York Statistics
Annual Road MilesTotal in State – 114,365
Vehicle Miles Driven – 127,230,000
Vehicles Registered – 10,283,907
Stolen – 15,313
State population19,453,561
Most popular vehicleNissan Rogue
Percentage of Uninsured/ Underinsured6.10%
State Rank – 50th
Total Driving-related Deaths2009–2018
Speeding – 3,327
DUI – 3,233
Full Coverage Average PremiumsLiability – $840.00
Collision – $414.27
Comprehensive – $178.10
Cheapest ProvidersGeico and USAA
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

The Empire State, known for its financial and economic clout and as the heart of arts and culture in the United States, expanded rapidly after it was founded in the early 1600s.

Part of its growth was due to its location, which allowed easy access to transportation via its ports, extensive rail lines, road routes, and airways that connect throughout the country and worldwide. And with subways, buses, and railroads that lead to nearby cities and states, it has the most complex commuter system in the country.

Cars are just one part of that network. Chances are, if you live in New York City, you don’t drive. But if you need to hit the road in the Empire State, you must buy car insurance.

That’s where we come in. In this guide to New York auto insurance, you’ll learn about the coverage you should buy, top insurers’ rates, and everything else you need to know.

If you can’t wait one New York minute to start comparison shopping, enter your ZIP code in our free online tool.

Table of Contents

New York Car Insurance Coverage and Rates

Consumer Reports recommends that car insurance buyers shop around for price every few years. Among their membership, 62 percent of those who switched insurers in the past five years said they had found a better price.

If you lack the time to compare prices, you may stay with the same carrier out of convenience, despite better options at other companies. Some of us could use more money, and comparison shopping may help lower another one of your expenses.

Below, we’ll go through the minimum coverage you need in the Empire State, how much the top insurers charge, and more aspects of car insurance prices.

So, get ready to learn how to get a fair price.

What is New York’s car culture?

Before you learn about car insurance coverage, you might be curious to know how cars influence New Yorkers’ daily lives.

The Hartford reports that many New York residents like to drive practical cars, such as the Toyota Camry and the Honda Civic. New Yorkers also love pickups and SUVs, among them the Nissan Rogue and the Chevrolet Silverado.

And let’s not forget about their passion for race cars and classic cars, which shows in the many racetracks and car shows statewide.

How much coverage is required to meet New York minimum limits?

New York is a no-fault insurance state. That means that if another driver causes an accident that harms you, you must file a claim with your own insurance company to pay your medical bills and damages.

The state requires drivers to carry minimum liability insurance to pay for accident claims. According to the New York Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV), your insurance coverage must meet these requirements:

  • $25,000 of bodily injury liability coverage per person/$50,000 per accident
  • $10,000 of property damage coverage (per accident you cause)
  • $50,000 for basic no-fault personal injury protection per person/$100,000 for the death for two or more people in an accident
  • $25,000 per person/$50,000 per accident of uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage for bodily injury

If you don’t carry coverage that meets these requirements, you may face several penalties, including the loss of your license.

Your liability insurance coverage must remain in effect while your car registration is valid, even if you don’t use the vehicle (there are exceptions for motorcycles). It must also be New York state insurance coverage issued by a company licensed by the State Department of Financial Services and New York DMV-certified. It must be in the vehicle registrant’s name and remain under their name. Out-of-state insurance isn’t acceptable.

One way to avoid filing a potential lawsuit is to buy more coverage than the minimum required to pay for all of your injuries or vehicle damage.

For instance, you can choose to purchase supplementary uninsured/underinsured motorists (SUM) coverage, based on your policy limits, up to $250,000 per person, per accident/$500,000 per accident.

What are forms of financial responsibility in New York?

New York law requires drivers to carry proof of insurance or financial responsibility to pay for accidents they cause.

Acceptable forms of proof of financial responsibility are:

  • A paper or electronic insurance ID card
  • A copy of your car’s current insurance policy
  • A valid insurance binder (a temporary form of car insurance)
  • Surety bond
  • Self-insurance (if you own 25 vehicles or more)
  • Cash or a security deposit of $150,000 or more with the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV)

You must show proof of insurance when you register vehicles, at traffic stops, and after accidents, so make sure you’re carrying it before you drive.

How much percentage of income are New York premiums?

Car insurance prices vary across the country. Below are New Yorkers’ annual incomes, together with the average yearly cost of car insurance premiums and the percentage of their earnings that go to car insurance every year.

New York Insurance as a Percentage of Income201220132014
Full coverage$1,273.70$1,301.49$1,327.82
Disposable income$46,010$45,710$47,446
Insurance as percentage of income2.77%2.85%2.80%
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

In 2014, the average New Yorker’s disposable (after-tax) income was $47,446, and the median cost of an annual full coverage premium was $1,327.82. Based on those figures, on average, nearly 3 percent of residents’ yearly earnings pay for car insurance.

On average, Americans pay $981.77 yearly for full coverage. The average annual full coverage premium in New York costs $400 more than it does nationwide.

Compared to neighboring Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Rhode Island, Connecticut, Massachusetts, and Vermont, residents in only the last three states paid less for auto insurance than New Yorkers. Massachusetts and Connecticut residents spent about $200 less for premiums than those of New York, while Vermonters’ premiums averaged $746.79 annually.

The one constant is that prices tend to rise for everyone yearly. Auto insurance premiums increased slightly everywhere, often by $50 to $100, from 2012 to 2014.

How much of your income pays for car insurance? Try our free calculator below and see.

CalculatorPro

What are the core coverages in New York?

Now, let’s see how much core coverage generally costs in New York. The figures below from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) show the price ranges from liability to full coverage. Expect the cost of premiums to continue to rise from 2019 and beyond.

Core Car Insurance Coverage in New YorkAverage Premium
Liability$840.00
Collision$414.27
Comprehensive$178.10
Full coverage $1,432.37
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

The premiums tend to cost more than the national average, which isn’t too surprising given that the Empire State ranks as the fourth-most expensive for full coverage insurance. As we mentioned earlier, New York has minimum insurance coverage requirements. If possible, experts suggest buying more than the minimum amount required.

Read on to find out about additional coverage options.

What additional liability is available in New York?

As we mentioned earlier, besides bodily injury liability, New York state requires drivers to buy additional liability in the form of personal injury protection (PIP) and uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage.

The data below from the NAIC centers on loss ratios for MedPay, PIP, and uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage. A loss ratio measures how much a company pays in claims to how much it earns in premiums.

Additional Liability Coverage in New YorkLoss Ratio – 2015Loss Ratio – 2014Loss Ratio – 2013
Personal Injury Protection (PIP) 72.66%70.58%72.29%
Medical Payments (Med Pay) 76.50%63.73%56.96%
Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist Coverage58.87%55.96%57.16%
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

Looking at the percentages above, if a company’s loss ratio is over 100 percent, it pays more in claims than it earns. A loss ratio of over 75 percent is already high. However, if a company’s loss ratio is too low, at 40 percent, it pays fewer claims.

Companies with ratios that are neither too high nor too low have a balance of profits versus losses. Unless a company’s loss ratio is high for several years in a row, a high loss ratio doesn’t mean an insurance company faces bankruptcy. More than likely, it means the company will raise its rates soon.

The loss ratios from 2012–2014 are low, as shown above, which could mean insurance companies don’t pay all the claims they receive. PIP coverage requirements could affect these numbers, as insurance companies may pay those claims first.

PIP will help pay your medical bills if you suffer injuries in a crash. Uninsured and underinsured coverage will pay bills if the other driver has little or no insurance.

6.1 percent of New York drivers don’t have insurance, which ranks the state 50th for uninsured drivers nationwide.

Though this percentage is low compared to other states, you don’t want to get stuck paying bills from an accident with an uninsured or underinsured driver. New York requires uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage, and it helps pay for damages those motorists may cause.

What add-ons, endorsements, and riders are available in New York?

Below is more coverage you can add to a basic car insurance plan for more protection tailored to your needs.

  • Guaranteed auto protection (GAP)
  • Personal umbrella policy (PUP)
  • Rental reimbursement
  • Pay-as-you-drive or usage-based insurance
  • Emergency roadside assistance
  • Mechanical breakdown insurance
  • Non-owner car insurance
  • Modified car insurance coverage
  • Classic car insurance

These options help you customize the perfect coverage just for you.

Among pay-as-you-go or usage-based insurers, Allstate’s Drivewise program operates in New York. Drivers who qualify may receive discounts of up to 30 percent. The program tracks users’ driving habits through a telematics device installed in the vehicle’s diagnostic port.

If you avoid speeds of 80 miles per hour or above and drive less than 30 miles daily outside of 10 p.m. to 4 a.m. without hard braking, you may get the maximum discount. Users must operate their vehicles for at least 90 days over six months to qualify for the discount.

Do gender and age affect my car insurance in New York?

We’ve partnered with Quadrant Data to bring you the information below. It’s based on coverage the state population has purchased and includes rates for high-risk drivers and those who choose to buy more than the state minimum. That covers other types of insurance the state doesn’t require.

As you’ll see below, gender is a factor in setting car insurance rates, but age also affects them, as well. Many insurers create gender and age profiles based on accident data, often charging young males more for car insurance.

Here’s how gender and age affect rates in New York.

CompanyMarried 35-year-old FemaleMarried 35-year-old MaleMarried 60-year-old FemaleMarried 60-year-old MaleSingle 17-year-old FemaleSingle 17-year-old MaleSingle 25-year-old FemaleSingle 25-year-old Male
Allstate$3,193.78$2,980.04$3,012.93$3,052.97$9,411.78$10,059.13$3,106.83$3,110.26
Geico$1,775.96$1,709.98$1,723.35$1,698.04$3,737.26$5,542.24$1,598.20$1,640.87
Liberty Mutual$4,808.02$4,808.02$4,476.84$4,476.84$9,371.20$14,468.63$4,808.02$5,108.28
Nationwide$3,003.69$3,003.69$2,829.30$2,829.30$5,431.46$8,143.12$3,003.69$3,859.22
Progressive$2,317.74$2,134.30$1,831.64$1,867.64$7,736.99$8,515.77$2,948.94$2,816.17
State Farm$2,838.51$2,838.51$2,481.13$2,481.13$8,316.70$10,504.50$3,126.63$3,289.54
Travelers$3,320.74$3,298.93$3,020.14$3,202.94$7,651.80$9,050.23$3,491.99$3,593.56
USAA$1,961.37$1,928.07$1,776.70$1,780.28$7,919.49$9,428.85$2,515.85$2,782.87
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

Sixty-year-olds of both sexes typically pay the lowest car insurance rates. Seventeen-year-olds don’t have much freedom in pricing with Liberty Mutual, as they face the highest auto insurance fees compared to competitors.

What are the cheapest rates by ZIP code in New York?

Location matters in real estate and car insurance rates. Cities and towns with higher populations and accident rates are riskier to insure, so premiums there may cost more. Here are the prices in New York state by ZIP code. The first table shows the 25 most expensive ZIP codes followed by the 25 least expensive in the next table.

ZIP CodesAllstateGEICOLiberty MutualNationwideProgressiveState FarmTravelersUSAA
11212$11,490.25 $5,780.57 $17,558.88 $10,621.33 $8,522.66 $11,877.04 $11,880.71 $8,278.50
11233$11,490.25 $5,780.57 $17,558.88 $10,621.33 $8,522.66 $11,596.36 $11,775.55 $8,278.50
11213$11,490.25 $5,780.57 $17,558.88 $10,621.33 $8,079.76 $11,586.05 $11,775.55 $8,278.50
11207$11,490.25 $5,780.57 $17,558.88 $10,621.33 $7,402.08 $11,837.38 $11,880.71 $8,278.50
11225$11,490.25 $5,780.57 $17,558.88 $10,621.33 $8,029.23 $11,586.05 $10,496.11 $7,853.79
11216$11,490.25 $5,780.57 $17,558.88 $10,621.33 $7,438.55 $11,586.05 $10,870.21 $7,853.79
11221$11,490.25 $5,780.57 $17,558.88 $10,621.33 $7,402.08 $11,617.80 $10,870.21 $7,853.79
11239$11,528.93 $5,780.57 $17,558.88 $10,621.33 $7,489.08 $10,737.34 $10,302.35 $8,278.50
11203$8,813.88 $5,300.14 $17,558.88 $10,621.33 $8,079.76 $11,480.17 $11,880.71 $8,278.50
11236$8,848.06 $5,300.14 $17,558.88 $10,621.33 $8,609.66 $10,840.54 $11,880.71 $8,278.50
11208$8,848.06 $5,780.57 $17,558.88 $10,621.33 $7,844.91 $11,613.31 $10,302.35 $8,278.50
11206$11,490.25 $5,780.57 $17,558.88 $9,447.68 $6,585.30 $11,642.66 $9,353.55 $7,853.79
11226$9,208.96 $5,300.14 $17,558.88 $9,213.53 $8,159.70 $11,144.66 $10,496.11 $8,278.50
11234$9,399.54 $5,300.14 $15,452.41 $9,480.89 $7,716.90 $10,639.74 $11,651.31 $8,278.50
11235$9,399.54 $5,300.14 $15,452.41 $9,480.89 $8,066.79 $10,273.23 $11,115.43 $8,278.50
11210$9,208.96 $5,300.14 $15,452.41 $9,480.89 $7,955.87 $9,894.11 $11,651.31 $8,278.50
11237$8,813.88 $4,510.55 $17,558.88 $10,621.33 $7,437.15 $11,621.22 $8,686.59 $7,573.76
11238$9,132.69 $4,187.43 $17,558.88 $9,447.68 $7,438.55 $11,586.05 $9,353.55 $7,853.79
11223$9,399.54 $5,300.14 $15,452.41 $9,480.89 $8,066.79 $8,572.42 $11,115.43 $8,278.50
11230$9,208.96 $5,300.14 $15,452.41 $9,480.89 $8,066.79 $8,618.20 $11,115.43 $8,278.50
11241$9,132.69 $3,457.75 $17,558.88 $10,621.33 $7,489.08 $10,797.26 $7,946.07 $8,278.50
11243$9,132.69 $3,457.75 $17,558.88 $10,621.33 $7,489.08 $10,797.26 $7,946.07 $8,278.50
11229$9,208.96 $5,300.14 $15,452.41 $9,480.89 $7,716.90 $8,546.86 $11,115.43 $8,278.50
11205$9,208.96 $4,510.55 $17,558.88 $9,447.68 $6,126.60 $11,180.76 $9,353.55 $7,573.76
11242$8,767.36 $3,457.75 $17,558.88 $10,621.33 $7,489.08 $10,797.26 $7,946.07 $8,278.50
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Compare RatesStart Now →
ZipcodeAllstateGEICOLiberty MutualNationwideProgressiveState FarmTravelersUSAA
14830$3,194.85 $1,814.79 $3,958.87 $2,385.41 $2,084.94 $2,758.50 $2,915.43 $2,723.90
14845$3,194.85 $1,756.70 $3,932.34 $2,385.41 $2,041.98 $3,033.95 $2,915.43 $2,765.03
14814$3,194.85 $1,756.70 $3,932.34 $2,385.41 $2,084.94 $3,025.03 $2,915.43 $2,765.03
14870$3,194.85 $1,814.79 $3,958.87 $2,385.41 $2,367.49 $2,730.17 $2,915.43 $2,723.90
14903$3,194.85 $1,756.70 $3,932.34 $2,385.41 $2,084.94 $3,059.81 $2,915.43 $2,765.03
14905$3,194.85 $1,756.70 $3,932.34 $2,385.41 $2,254.47 $3,090.90 $2,915.43 $2,765.03
14904$3,194.85 $1,756.70 $3,932.34 $2,385.41 $2,254.47 $3,103.59 $2,915.43 $2,765.03
14871$3,194.85 $1,756.70 $3,958.87 $2,385.41 $2,297.44 $2,778.21 $2,915.43 $3,026.99
14894$3,194.85 $1,756.70 $3,932.34 $2,385.41 $2,254.47 $3,122.28 $2,915.43 $2,765.03
14901$3,194.85 $1,756.70 $3,932.34 $2,385.41 $2,254.47 $3,124.85 $2,915.43 $2,765.03
14821$3,317.92 $1,814.79 $3,958.87 $2,385.41 $2,457.87 $2,733.47 $3,111.25 $2,723.90
13850$3,268.98 $2,002.78 $3,888.71 $2,461.06 $2,247.71 $3,054.92 $3,124.57 $2,621.94
14816$3,194.85 $1,756.70 $3,932.34 $2,385.41 $2,387.80 $3,505.38 $2,915.43 $2,912.29
13795$3,268.98 $2,002.78 $3,888.71 $2,461.06 $2,428.42 $3,022.33 $3,337.03 $2,621.94
13748$3,268.98 $2,002.78 $3,888.71 $2,461.06 $2,428.42 $3,031.05 $3,337.03 $2,621.94
13603$3,496.52 $1,921.00 $4,420.81 $2,554.63 $2,437.22 $2,982.94 $3,069.67 $2,165.68
13612$3,496.52 $1,921.00 $4,420.81 $2,554.63 $2,437.22 $2,986.14 $3,069.67 $2,165.68
13616$3,496.52 $1,921.00 $4,420.81 $2,554.63 $2,437.22 $2,991.64 $3,069.67 $2,165.68
13606$3,496.52 $1,921.00 $4,420.81 $2,554.63 $2,437.22 $3,009.62 $3,069.67 $2,165.68
13601$3,496.52 $1,921.00 $4,420.81 $2,554.63 $2,437.22 $3,016.62 $3,069.67 $2,165.68
13685$3,496.52 $1,921.00 $4,420.81 $2,554.63 $2,437.22 $3,023.87 $3,069.67 $2,165.68
13656$3,496.52 $1,921.00 $4,420.81 $2,554.63 $2,455.28 $3,020.25 $3,069.67 $2,165.68
13640$3,496.52 $1,921.00 $4,420.81 $2,554.63 $2,455.28 $3,023.41 $3,069.67 $2,165.68
13634$3,496.52 $1,921.00 $4,420.81 $2,554.63 $2,437.22 $3,043.04 $3,069.67 $2,165.68
13607$3,496.52 $1,921.00 $4,420.81 $2,554.63 $2,455.28 $3,026.58 $3,069.67 $2,165.68
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

In 11241 and other nearby ZIP codes, Geico customers pay as much as $7,000 to $12,000 less than with pricier insurers. So if you’re thinking of moving, consider your ZIP code in your car insurance costs.

What are the cheapest rates by city in New York?

Below are the most expensive cities in New York state.

AverageCity
$6,461.36Brooklyn
$6,413.13Brooklyn
$6,356.48Brooklyn
$6,316.33Brooklyn
$6,137.15Brooklyn
$6,110.07Brooklyn
$6,109.48Brooklyn
$5,997.24Brooklyn
$5,961.79Brooklyn
$5,952.35Brooklyn
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

The borough of Brooklyn dominates the list. These are the least expensive cities:

AverageCity
$2729.58Corning
$2753.21Horseheads
$2757.47Big Flats
$2761.36Painted Post
$2761.81Elmira
$2786.89Elmira
$2788.48Elmira
$2789.24Pine City
$2790.81Wellsburg
$2791.13Elmira
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

In these cities, auto insurance costs are $3,000 to $4,000 less than in areas around Brooklyn. That’s another reason why it makes sense to compare rates among different companies.

Compare quotes from the top car insurance companies and save!

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Best State Car Insurance Companies

Consumer Reports also found in their surveys over the years that car insurance companies tend to perform consistently over time, and some get high scores regularly. That often comes down to a company’s long-term record of customer satisfaction.

The news report below goes into more detail about the CR survey:

But, with all of the companies and coverage out there, it can be hard to decide what’s right for you. That’s the downside of having a lot of options available. On the upside, we’ve gathered information about the essential factors car insurance shoppers should consider when they choose a carrier.

Are you ready to read more? You’ll be glad you did. The knowledge can help you while you shop around.

What are the financial ratings of the largest companies in New York?

A.M. Best ranks companies based on their financial strength. And, as we discussed above, loss ratio is part of that and can reflect the stability of a company and whether it may charge customers more to make up for any differences. These are A.M. Best’s ratings for some of the top companies.

CompanyFinancial Rating
AllstateA+
Amtrust NGHA-
GeicoA++
Liberty MutualA
Nationwide CorpA+
NYCM InsuranceA
ProgressiveA+
State FarmA
Travelers GroupA++
USAAA++
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

Companies with the highest rating of A++ remain profitable despite paying claims regularly.

Which car insurance companies have the best ratings in New York?

Now, let’s review customer satisfaction ratings. J.D. Power’s U.S. Auto Insurance Study measures car insurance customers’ overall satisfaction. These are the results:

InsurerPointsPower Circles
Allstate831three
Geico823three
Liberty Mutual819three
MetLife836four
Nationwide822three
New York average839three
New York Central Mutual869five
Progressive815two
State Farm845four
Travelers845four
USAA884five
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

New York Central Mutual earned the top spot, with five power circles, to become among the best. On the opposite end of the scale, Progressive netted only two power circles.

USAA also received high marks, but because it’s available only to military personnel and their families, J.D. Power didn’t include USAA in its official results.

Which car insurance companies have the most complaints in New York?

Praise is one thing, but when you evaluate a car insurer, it helps to look at customers’ criticisms of the company. The data below shows complaints about the top New York insurers in 2017 from the NAIC closed complaint ratio report.

Company NameNational Median
Complaint Ratio
Company Complaint
Ratio 2017
Total Complaints
2017
Allstate Insurance Group1.5163
Amtrust NGH Group102
GeicoN/AN/AN/A
Liberty Mutual Group15.95222
Nationwide Corp Group1.2825
NYCM Insurance Group102
Progressive Group1.75120
State Farm Group1.441482
Travelers Group1.092
USAA GroupN/AN/AN/A
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

A complaint ratio reflects the number of complaints a company receives. It’s also tied to an insurer’s market share or the number of customers it serves in a certain geographic area. A ratio of “one” is average.

Though State Farm had the most complaints, its ratio was less than one. It serves more customers in New York than many of its competitors, but not everyone has a grievance. Even if several do, they don’t affect its overall ratio. On the flip side, a company with half the market share of State Farm, Liberty Mutual, received fewer complaints, yet its ratio was six times higher than the average.

What are the cheapest car insurance companies in New York?

Here’s how the top insurers’ rates compare to the state average car insurance prices.

CompanyAverageCompared to State Average (+/-)Compared to State Average (%)
Allstate$4,740.96$451.089.51%
Geico$2,428.24-$1,861.65-76.67%
Liberty Mutual$6,540.73$2,250.8534.41%
Nationwide$4,012.93-$276.95-6.90%
Progressive$3,771.15-$518.74-13.76%
State Farm$4,484.58$194.704.34%
Travelers$4,578.79$288.916.31%
USAA$3,761.69-$528.20-14.04%
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

Geico is the cheapest company in New York, costing 77 percent less than the New York average. Liberty Mutual’s premiums, however, are over 34 percent higher than the state average.

Does my commute affect my car insurance in New York?

With some insurers, the longer your commute, the more you’ll pay, generally, because your accident risk tends to increase with the more miles you drive.

Company10-Mile Commute25-Mile Commute
Allstate$4,675.15$4,806.77
Geico$2,358.45$2,498.03
Liberty Mutual$6,354.63$6,726.83
Nationwide$4,012.93$4,012.93
Progressive$3,771.15$3,771.15
State Farm$4,322.30$4,646.86
Travelers$4,578.79$4,578.79
USAA$3,723.73$3,799.64
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

Nationwide, Progressive, and Travelers don’t factor distance into their rates. Of the insurers who base their prices on mileage, Liberty Mutual charges the highest rate at $372.

So if you drive a lot, it’s better to avoid companies that tie their rates to mileage.

Can coverage level change my car insurance rate with companies in New York?

Full or high coverage will give the most protection in case of an accident. With low- or medium-level coverage, you may end up paying some costs for a crash out of pocket.

As you’ll see below, with some insurers, full coverage may be affordable.

CompanyLow CoverageMedium CoverageHigh Coverage
Allstate$4,372.19$4,372.19$5,134.16
Geico$2,287.62$2,416.55$2,580.54
Liberty Mutual$6,237.28$6,520.87$6,864.04
Nationwide$3,752.51$3,975.76$4,310.54
Progressive$3,559.37$3,745.62$4,008.45
State Farm$4,240.05$4,511.46$4,702.24
Travelers$4,309.32$4,522.76$4,904.29
USAA$3,644.21$3,741.21$3,899.63
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

With Geico, the difference from the highest to lowest coverage amounts to just under $300.

How does my credit history affect my car insurance rate with companies in New York?

Another critical factor in car insurance costs is your credit score. Companies in New York also use their own insurance score, which sometimes includes your credit rating. The video below explains this concept further:

Here’s how auto insurance premium prices compare in the Empire State for drivers with poor, fair, and good credit scores.

CompanyPoorFairGood
Allstate$6,865.50$5,985.24$5,985.24
Geico$3,042.53$4,012.93$4,012.93
Liberty Mutual$9,156.87$3,970.78$3,970.78
Nationwide$4,012.93$3,961.90$3,961.90
Progressive$6,065.81$3,944.57$3,944.57
State Farm$6,331.07$3,041.52$3,041.52
Travelers$6,396.79$2,913.64$2,913.64
USAA$5,800.63$2,235.78$2,235.78
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

As it turns out, New York residents generally have good credit scores.

Experian found that the average New Yorker’s credit score in 2017 was 688, which was higher than the national average of 675. New Yorkers own an average of 3.34 credit cards and carry over $6,000 in credit card debt.

As shown above, Geico and Nationwide offer the lowest rates to drivers with poor credit rankings. This shows that some insurers factor credit history into their prices more than others, and it can help to know which ones give it the most weight.

How does my driving record change my rates with car insurance companies in New York?

Your driving record is another major factor in your insurance premiums. Here’s how they change among the top companies in New York State.

CompanyClean RecordWith One AccidentWith One DUIWith One Speeding Violation
Allstate$4,004.39$4,004.39$5,884.41$5,884.41
Geico$1,894.00$2,064.88$3,860.07$3,860.07
Liberty Mutual$5,197.79$5,197.79$10,569.55$10,569.55
Nationwide$3,042.44$3,042.44$6,853.01$6,853.01
Progressive$3,664.67$3,664.67$4,066.27$4,066.27
State Farm$4,267.85$4,267.85$4,701.32$4,701.32
Travelers$3,901.71$4,896.91$4,964.33$4,964.33
USAA$3,348.28$3,402.69$4,893.09$4,893.09
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

Not every company adjusts its rates for certain driving penalties. For instance, Liberty Mutual keeps rates for drivers who have one accident the same. Like other companies, for one DUI offense or a speeding ticket, Liberty will raise your rates. Some companies do so more than others.

Which car insurance companies are the largest in New York?

Here’s how the top insurers compare by loss ratio, market share, and direct premiums written in New York.

Company NameDirect Premiums WrittenLoss RatioMarket Share
Allstate Insurance Group$1,843,730,00059.24%13.90%
Amtrust NGH Group$291,750,00069.66%2.20%
GEICO$4,233,525,00081.66%31.93%
Liberty Mutual Group$731,396,00061.45%5.52%
Nationwide Corp Group$302,854,00063.35%2.28%
NYCM Insurance Group$327,366,00063.55%2.47%
Progressive Group$1,284,132,00062.23%9.68%
State Farm Group$1,758,370,00067.43%13.26%
Travelers Group$529,676,00059.45%3.99%
USAA Group$392,346,00073.01%2.96%
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

Geico has the largest market share, but also the biggest loss ratio, at over 80 percent. As we’ve mentioned, many of the largest insurers have the financial resources to remain stable despite paying several claims, which could bankrupt smaller companies.

How many car insurance companies are available in New York?

Domestic insurers were formed in New York, while foreign insurers were founded elsewhere, but are licensed to operate in the Empire State.

Out of 882 total insurers who operate in New York, 173 are domestic and 709 are foreign. These totals may include not only property/casualty insurers, but also charter groups and self-insurance companies.

Free High-Risk Insurance Comparison

Compare quotes from the top car insurance companies and save!

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

New York Laws

Laws vary from state to state. Lots of regulations exist, and the legal mumbo jumbo surrounding them can be confusing.

To help you cut through the clutter, below, we’ll cover the laws you must know when you buy car insurance, when you get a license, and when you hit the road.

Get ready to learn more about driving and car insurance regulations.

What are the car insurance laws in New York?

In this section, we’ll go over New York laws that control car insurance rates, windshield replacement, high-risk coverage, fraud, and statutes of limitation.

How State Laws for Insurance Are Determined

The State of New York and the Department of Financial Services set insurance rates based on the National Association of Insurance Commissioners’ standards.

Insurance companies must get prior approval from the state financial department before filing rates and forms in New York. For prices, the Department of Financial Services requires prior consent only if they are a certain percentage above or sometimes below the rates a company has filed before.

Windshield Coverage

New York law lets you replace a windshield with aftermarket parts if they are “equal or exceed the comparable OEM crash part in terms of fit, form, finish, quality, and performance.” If you use them, the information must appear on the estimate.

Insurers may also offer zero-deductible policies for windshield glass replacement. Comprehensive car insurance, which covers damage from acts of god such as vandalism, theft, fire, and natural disasters, sometimes covers windshield replacement.

High-risk Insurance

If you’ve been convicted of several offenses such as driving without insurance or a DUI, insurance companies may consider you a high risk to insure. That may make it harder to get insured through the open marketplace.

In New York, by law, SR-22 car insurance forms aren’t required. High-risk drivers have an alternative. The New York Automobile Insurance Plan (NYAIP) will cover motorists who have tried and failed to get auto insurance within the past 60 days at rates not above those applicable under the plan. The coverage, however, isn’t cheap. In 2012, the average NYAIP premium was $2,283.

You must also provide proof that you tried and failed to get automobile insurance in New York within the past 60 days and haven’t been able to get coverage at rates that don’t exceed those available under the plan.

Low-cost Insurance

Though New York has a program to help high-risk drivers, it doesn’t have one for low-income drivers.

California, Hawaii, and New Jersey are the only states with government-funded programs to help low-income drivers pay for their car insurance.

Automobile Insurance Fraud in New York

Misrepresenting facts on insurance claims, submitting false claims, and faking accidents are among the most common forms of car insurance fraud.

According to the Insurance Information Institute (III), insurance applicants, policyholders, third-party claimants, and insurance professionals are among those who commit fraud. The III reports that New York is among only five other states that require auto insurance photo inspections for claims:

“Photo inspections uncovered about $1.8 billion in pre-existing auto damage in New York state from 2014 to 2018. This saved insurers from paying $128 million in false claims on vehicles. In addition, for every dollar invested in pre-insurance inspections, $34 in false claims payouts were avoided.”

Car insurance fraud is a crime under Article 176. New York law defines six types of penalties:

  • Fifth degree – Committing any fraudulent act to get insurance payments improperly, which is a Class A misdemeanor (176.10)
  • Fourth degree – Committing insurance fraud and wrongfully receiving assets of more than $1,000 is insurance fraud, which is a Class E felony (176.15)
  • Third degree – Carrying out insurance fraud and unfairly gaining $3,000 or more in assets is insurance fraud, which is a Class D felony (176.20).
  • Second degree – Committing insurance fraud and getting $50,000 or more of assets is insurance fraud, which is a Class C felony (176.25).
  • First degree – Committing insurance fraud and obtaining $1 million or more in assets is insurance fraud, which is a Class B felony. (176.30)
  • Aggravated insurance fraud – Committing another act of insurance fraud within five years of a prior conviction, which is a Class D felony (176.35).

If you’ve been a victim of insurance fraud, you may file a complaint online with the New York Attorney General’s Auto Insurance Fraud Unit or call the fraud hotline at (888) 372-8369.

Statute of Limitations

The statute of limitations is the time you have left to file and resolve an insurance claim or bring a lawsuit. In New York state, drivers have three years to file a personal injury or a property damage insurance claim or lawsuit.

Evidence can degrade, and witnesses can be hard to keep track of over time, so it’s best to file sooner rather than later.

New York-specific Laws

Like other states, New York has some driving laws you won’t find elsewhere. These are some ordinances that apply only to certain parts of the state:

  • Especially in New York City, on some streets, you can turn left only at certain times of the day. Pay attention to the signs before you make these or any other turns.
  • In the Village of Sag Harbor, you can’t take off your clothes in your vehicle.
  • Drivers in West Hampton Dunes must not make U-turns.
  • The Town of Oyster Bay prohibits fancy car horns, so your car must honk like everyone else’s — without the cute bells and whistles.
  • It’s illegal to sleep inside your vehicle in Southampton when you park on any street, beach access road, or park, parking lot, or recreational area the village owns or maintains. Violators face fines of up to $1,000 or 15 days in jail.

Whether or not they affect your driving in the Empire State, some quirky rules remain on the books.

What are the vehicle licensing laws in New York?

Here we’ll cover regulations regarding getting and maintaining a license to drive in the Empire State: the recent REAL ID law, penalties, and driver licensing requirements.

REAL ID

Starting October 1, 2020, to comply with the federal REAL ID Act, you’ll need a REAL ID driver’s license, permit, or identification card to board domestic flights or enter federal buildings.

Otherwise, you don’t need to get one. A valid U.S. passport is already REAL ID-compliant, so you can use it to board a flight.

To apply for a REAL ID, you can visit your local Department of Motor Vehicles. Below are the original or certified documents the DMV suggests you bring:

  • Proof of identity, such as a valid license, birth certificate, or passport, with your full first, middle (if applicable), and last name. Your name, as it appears on your proof of identity, will appear on your card. If the name on your application doesn’t match the one on your ID, lawful status, and Social Security card, you must bring court or government-issued proof, such as a marriage license, divorce decree, adoption, or court order.
  • Proof of Social Security number or Social Security number ineligibility. If you have a valid New York license, permit, or ID card, you must bring your original Social Security card or W-2 with the full SSN. If you don’t have a New York state driver’s license or identification card, you must bring your Social Security card or a letter from the Social Security Administration that proves your ineligibility for a Social Security number.
  • Proof of your date of birth
  • Proof of U.S. citizenship, lawful permanent residency, or temporary lawful U.S. status
  • Two different proofs of New York State residence, such as a utility bill, bank or mortgage statement (P.O. box is not acceptable). This address will show up on your card.

Penalties for Driving Without Insurance

Whenever law enforcement pulls you over, you must show your license, registration, and insurance card.

As we mentioned before, in New York, you must carry proof of insurance or financial responsibility with you at all times. If you can’t, according to the state DMV, you’ll face the following penalties:

  • A fine of up to $1,500 if you’re involved in an accident and a $750 civil penalty
  • License and registration suspension for up to one year if you’re without insurance after 90 days and can’t pay the below fees

If you let your insurance lapse, the DMV will charge you per day at the following rates:

  • For 1–30 days – $8 per day
  • For 31–60 days – $10 per day
  • For 61–90 days – $12 per day

A lapse in insurance and a conviction for driving without insurance can cost you up to $2,400.

Ultimately, driving without insurance can cost you — sometimes more than buying insurance — and it’s a risk that’s better to avoid.

Next, we’ll go over teen driving laws.

Teen Driver Laws

In New York, you must be at least 16 years and six months old to drive without adult supervision. Per New York’s graduated licensing law, below are the requirements for getting a learner’s license.

Requirements for
Getting a Learner's
License
Time/Age
Mandatory holding periodSix months
Minimum supervised driving time50 hours, 15 of which must be at night
Minimum age16
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

Young drivers with a learner’s permit must follow these passenger and nighttime restrictions until they meet the age requirement to carry a full license:

New York Learner's
License Restrictions
Details
Nighttime restrictions9 p.m.–5 a.m. except for NYC (unsupervised driving prohibited at all times) and Long Island (limited daytime unsupervised driving)
Passenger restrictions (family members excepted unless noted otherwise)no more than one passenger younger than age 21
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

These are the minimum ages when the DMV abandons the restrictions:

Minimum age
at which
restrictions
may be lifted:
Details
Nighttime restrictionsUntil age 17 with driver education; until age 18 without (min. age – 17)
Passenger restrictionsUntil age 17 with driver education; until age 18 without (min. age – 17)
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

Once they receive a full license, teen drivers may take the wheel without restrictions.

Older Driver License Renewal Procedures

According to the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, older drivers must meet these requirements to renew their licenses:

  • Renew their licenses every eight years
  • Show proof of adequate vision at every renewal
  • Renew by mail or online at every renewal, without restrictions.

New York’s relaxed renewal process means older drivers can make fewer trips to the DMV.

New Residents

If you’ve moved from out of state, you must apply for a New York driver’s license at a DMV office within 30 days after you establish your residency.

Your out-of-state license must meet the following requirements:

  • have a picture
  • be valid or have been expired for fewer than 24 months
  • have been issued at least six months before your New York license application

You can’t exchange your license if it is or has been:

  • suspended or revoked
  • lost or stolen
  • a hardship or employment-only license
  • non-renewable or non-transferable

A New York license is valid for five years from the date of issue.

The news report below details a new Empire State law that allows undocumented immigrants to get driver’s licenses:

License Renewal Procedures

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) reports that drivers with New York licenses must renew them every eight years and provide proof of adequate vision at every renewal. They may renew online or through the mail.

Negligent Operator Treatment System (NOTS)

In New York, reckless driving interferes with the free and proper use of a public highway or endangers other drivers. It’s generally considered a misdemeanor. These are the potential penalties:

  • First offense – up to 30 days in jail and/or $100 to $300 in fines
  • Second offense (within 18 months) – up to 90 days in prison and/or $100 to $525 in fines
  • Third offense (in 18 months) – up to 180 days in jail and/or $100 to $1,125 in fines

One reckless driving conviction can add five points to your driving record and raise your insurance premiums.

What are the rules of the road in New York?

To remain a safe and responsible driver (and avoid penalties), it’s essential to stay on top of the current rules of the road.

Below, we’ll go over laws you should know regarding seat belt and car seat use, when you should keep right and move over, speed limits, automation, and more.

Fault Versus No-fault

As a no-fault state, drivers must file claims with their own insurance company, even when they’re not responsible for an accident.

The Empire State follows a doctrine of comparative fault for personal injury cases. That means a judge or a jury assigns each party involved in an accident a percentage of fault or responsibility.

For example, if a plaintiff who ran a red light was 60 percent at fault, and the other driver, who was speeding, was 40 percent responsible, the judge would reduce the plaintiff’s award by 60 percent.

This law firm video goes over the basics of the comparative negligence law:

Seat Belt and Car Seat Laws

Below are the seat belt and car seat laws in the Empire State.

Seat Belt Laws in New YorkDetails
Effective sinceDecember 1, 1984
Primary enforcementYes; effective 12/01/84
Age/Seats applicable16+ years / in front seat
First offense maximum fine$50
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

More fees for violating the seat belt law may also apply (besides the $50 fine). Primary enforcement means that law enforcement officers can pull drivers over if they see passengers who aren’t wearing seat belts.

New York State continues to consider requiring passengers in the back seat also to wear seat belts.

Follow these car seat laws to protect your child in case of a car accident:

Type of Car Seat RequiredAge
Child booster seatYounger than 2 years or until a child outgrows the manufacturer's top height or weight recommendations in a rear-facing child restraint; younger than 4 years unless they weigh more than 40 pounds and are seated where there is no available lap/shoulder belt; 4 through 7 years unless they're seated where there is no available lap/shoulder belt
Adult belt permissible8 through 15 years; children who weigh more than 40 pounds or children 4 through 7 years in a seating position where there is no available lap/shoulder belt
Preference for rear seatYes
Maximum base fine for first offense$100
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

As of November 1, 2019, New York law requires restraining children up to 2 years old who ride in a motor vehicle in a rear-facing child safety seat. Always follow the manufacturer’s height and weight requirements to restrain children safely in the right car seats.

Regarding riding the cargo areas of pickup trucks, it’s illegal in New York except in the following situations:

  • If the trip is five miles or less.
  • If the trip is five miles or more and if one-third or fewer of the passengers are standing, if suitable seats are securely attached, or there are side rails and a tailgate.
  • If the trip is five miles or more and fewer than five people age 17 or younger or at least one person, 18 or older, is in the cargo area.

Follow these restrictions to prevent injuring passengers, especially during sharp turns or sudden stops.

Keep Right and Move Over Laws

If you drive slower than the average speed of traffic in New York, you must keep right.

However, according to AAA, when an emergency vehicle, tow truck, or a maintenance vehicle with flashing lights is traveling in the same direction, you must use care, reduce speed, and move to a nearby lane.

When you obey these laws, you potentially avoid hitting people and vehicles. Watch this video for more details on New York’s move-over laws:

Speed Limits

These are the highest speed limits on New York roads to keep every driver safe.

Type of RoadwaySpeed Limit
Rural interstates65 mph
Urban interstates65 mph
Other limited access roads65 mph
Other roads55 mph
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

Keep your speed in check by looking at the posted speed limits on these and other roads.

Ridesharing

If you want to drive for rideshare services such as Uber and Lyft, among other requirements (which vary by company), according to the New York DMV, you must carry a New York license and insurance. Drivers must also be at least 19 years old.

Automation on the Road

New York limits the use of driverless cars on the road. According to the IIHS, New York is among the states that are testing automated or driverless vehicles. The tests require operators to be licensed and inside the car. They must also have liability insurance of $5 million.

The news report below explains more about driverless cars in the Empire State:

What are the safety laws in New York?

New York has several safety laws that control driving under the influence (DUI) and marijuana-impaired and distracted driving. In this section, we’ll cover the laws and the penalties involved in such risky behaviors.

DUI Laws

DUI is a crime in New York and can increase your insurance rates by $1,000 or more. Below are some facts about the state’s legal blood alcohol content (BAC) limit from Responsibility.org and the different levels of offenses:

Name for OffenseDriving While Intoxicated (DWI); High BAC Aggravated Driving While Intoxicated (ADWI)
BAC limit0.05 – DWAI, 0.08 – DUI
High BAC limit0.18
Criminal statusDWAI – First, traffic violation; Second and subsequent, misdemeanor;
DWI – First, misdemeanor;
Second in 10 years, class E felony;
Third and subsequent in 10 years, class D felony
Look-back period10 years for second offense
15 years for third and subsequent
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

The table below reveals more details about penalties and fines, which include New York’s two levels of DUI — driving while intoxicated (DWI) and aggravated driving while intoxicated (ADWI).

DUI PenalitiesALS or RevocationImprisonmentFine
First OffenseRevoked for at least six months
ADWI – One-year minimum
No minimum, but up to one year
ADWI – Up to one year
$500–$1,000;
ADWI – $1,000–$2,500
Second OffenseSecond in 10 years – One-year minimum;
ADWI – 18 months minimum
Five days minimum.
Second in 10 years – Up to four years.
ADWI – Up to four years
Second in 10 years – $1,000–$5,000;
ADWI – $1,000–$5,000
Third OffenseThird in 10 years – One-year minimum.
ADWI – 18 months minimum
10 days minimum.
Third in 10 years – Up to seven years;
ADWI – Up to seven years
Third in 10 years – $2,000–$10,000;
ADWI – $2,000–$10,000
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

With the rise in BAC levels, the penalties increase accordingly. These laws are strict for a reason and act as a deterrent. The safest thing to do to prevent severe injuries and death is not to drink and drive.

Marijuana-impaired Driving Laws

New York doesn’t have any specific laws for marijuana-impaired driving. However, that doesn’t mean you can’t get caught for drugged driving.

Law enforcement will charge drivers under the influence of marijuana with intoxicated driving. This charge carries many of the same penalties as drunk driving, such as fines, jail time, and license suspension.

Recreational marijuana use remains illegal in New York. However, in July 2019, Governor Andrew Cuomo approved the reduction of fines for possessing an ounce of the drug from $100 to $50.

The law also closes the public view loophole police officers have used as a reason to arrest those who possess the drug. Further, it automatically erases old convictions for this now decriminalized conduct.

CNN reports that the governor also announced recently that legalizing cannabis is among his priorities in 2020. Regarding medicinal use, chronic pain and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) are among the qualifying conditions.

Unfortunately, drugged driving is increasing, and the effects are just as bad — if not worse — than drunk or distracted driving. To avoid harming yourself and others, don’t drive while under the influence.

Distracted Driving Laws

Using a handheld device while you drive can be just as risky as a DUI. With the rise of the smartphone, distracted driving has become a bigger road hazard. Below are the New York laws over cellphone use while driving.

Handheld BanYoung Drivers – All Cellphone BanTexting BanEnforcement
All driversNot a lawAll driversPrimary
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

The American Automobile Association (AAA) states that “no person shall operate a motor vehicle while using a mobile telephone to engage in a call while the vehicle is in motion unless that person is using a hands-free device. Text messaging while driving is prohibited for all drivers.”

These laws are primary enforcement, which means that a police officer can pull you over for using your cellphone.

See the video below for more facts about the state’s ban on texting while driving:

For those who are addicted to drugs, alcohol, or even smartphones, treatment options are available.

Driving in New York

The dangers of driving in high-traffic situations in densely populated areas such as New York City lead some people to take public transportation instead.

Wherever you drive, it helps to stay informed about the hazards of car ownership and taking to the streets. Keep reading to learn all about vehicle theft, traffic fatalities, and more.

How many vehicle thefts occur in New York?

Some vehicles are more popular to steal than others. These are the top 10 most stolen cars in the Empire State.

Type of VehicleModel YearNumber Stolen
Honda Accord1997724
Honda Civic1998707
Toyota Camry2014500
Nissan Altima2015374
Dodge Caravan2000368
Ford Econoline E3502011339
Nissan Maxima1998328
Honda CR-V1997283
Toyota Corolla2010280
Jeep Cherokee/Grand Cherokee2015263
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

In keeping with drivers’ tendency to drive more practical cars, thieves, in turn, prefer to steal them. The 1997 Honda Accord and the 2014 Toyota Camry were among the most stolen vehicles.

Let’s look at Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) statistics on the vehicle thefts by city in the Empire State:

CityMotor
Vehicle
Thefts
Adams Village1
Addison Town and Village0
Akron Village1
Albany112
Albion Village11
Alexandria Bay Village0
Alfred Village1
Allegany Village0
Altamont Village0
Amherst Town41
Amity Town and Belmont Village0
Amityville Village3
Amsterdam9
Andover Village1
Angelica Village0
Arcade Village0
Ardsley Village0
Asharoken Village0
Attica Village0
Auburn16
Avon Village0
Bainbridge Village0
Baldwinsville Village0
Ballston Spa Village1
Batavia12
Bath Village1
Beacon6
Bedford Town4
Bethlehem Town6
Binghamton102
Black River0
Blooming Grove Town8
Bolton Town1
Boonville Village0
Brant Town2
Brewster1
Briarcliff Manor Village0
Brighton Town18
Brockport Village3
Brownville Village0
Buffalo835
Cairo Town0
Caledonia Village0
Cambridge Village0
Camden Village0
Camillus Town and Village8
Canajoharie Village2
Canandaigua5
Canastota Village5
Canisteo Village0
Canton Village0
Cape Vincent Village0
Carmel Town10
Carroll Town0
Carthage Village0
Cattaraugus Village0
Cayuga Heights Village0
Cazenovia Village0
Central Square Village0
Centre Island Village1
Cheektowaga Town115
Chester Town1
Chester Village3
Chittenango Village0
Cicero Town4
Clarkstown Town33
Clayton Village0
Clyde Village0
Cobleskill Village2
Coeymans Town4
Cohocton Town0
Cohoes18
Colonie Town38
Cooperstown Village0
Corning4
Cornwall Town1
Cornwall-on-Hudson Village0
Cortland5
Coxsackie Village0
Crawford Town2
Croton-on-Hudson Village0
Cuba Town0
Dansville Village1
Deerpark Town3
Delhi Village1
Depew Village6
DeWitt Town33
Dexter Village0
Dobbs Ferry Village1
Dolgeville Village0
Dryden Village0
Dunkirk14
Durham Town0
East Aurora-Aurora Town2
East Fishkill Town10
East Greenbush Town7
East Hampton Town4
East Hampton Village2
East Rochester Village2
Eastchester Town3
Eden Town2
Ellenville Village1
Ellicott Town4
Ellicottville0
Elmira27
Elmira Heights Village0
Elmira Town1
Elmsford Village2
Endicott Village14
Evans Town8
Fairport Village0
Fallsburg Town2
Fishkill Town6
Fishkill Village0
Floral Park Village4
Florida Village0
Fort Edward Village0
Fort Plain Village1
Frankfort Town1
Frankfort Village0
Fredonia Village2
Freeport Village35
Friendship Town0
Fulton City2
Garden City Village6
Gates Town49
Geddes Town5
Geneseo Village0
Geneva1
Germantown Town0
Glen Cove48
Glen Park Village0
Glens Falls1
Glenville Town7
Gloversville9
Goshen Town6
Goshen Village1
Gowanda Village3
Granville Village0
Great Neck Estates Village0
Greece Town77
Green Island Village4
Greenburgh Town22
Greene Village0
Greenport Town0
Greenwich Village0
Greenwood Lake Village5
Groton Village1
Guilderland Town1
Hamburg Town24
Hamburg Village2
Hamilton Village0
Hammondsport Village0
Hancock Village0
Harriman Village0
Harrison Town1
Hastings-on-Hudson Village3
Haverstraw Town20
Hempstead Village135
Herkimer Village40
Highlands Town0
Holley Village3
Homer Village0
Hoosick Falls Village1
Hornell0
Horseheads Village0
Hudson4
Hudson Falls Village2
Hunter Town0
Huntington Bay Village0
Hyde Park Town1
Ilion Village2
Independence Town0
Inlet Town0
Irvington Village0
Ithaca19
Jamestown53
Johnson City Village22
Jordan Village0
Kenmore Village5
Kensington Village1
Kent Town2
Kings Point Village2
Kingston9
Kirkland Town0
Lackawanna30
Lake Placid Village4
Lake Success Village0
Lakewood-Busti2
Lancaster Town11
Larchmont Village3
Le Roy Village0
Lewisboro Town0
Lewiston Town and Village12
Liberty Village6
Little Falls3
Liverpool Village0
Lloyd Harbor Village1
Lloyd Town6
Lockport22
Long Beach14
Lowville Village2
Lynbrook Village8
Macedon Town and Village3
Malone Village0
Malverne Village0
Mamaroneck Town3
Mamaroneck Village3
Manchester Village0
Manlius Town11
Marcellus Village0
Marlborough Town3
Massena Village6
Maybrook Village1
Mechanicville4
Medina Village7
Menands Village5
Middleport Village0
Middletown21
Monroe Village3
Montgomery Village2
Monticello Village7
Moravia Village0
Moriah Town0
Mount Hope Town2
Mount Morris Village3
Mount Pleasant Town0
Mount Vernon117
Nassau Village0
New Berlin Town0
New Castle Town1
New Hartford Town and Village5
New Paltz Town and Village1
New Rochelle61
New Windsor Town7
New York6,369
New York Mills Village1
Newark Village5
Newburgh53
Newburgh Town12
Niagara Falls186
Niagara Town8
Niskayuna Town11
Nissequogue Village1
Norfolk Town1
North Castle Town2
North Greenbush Town9
North Syracuse Village3
North Tonawanda36
Northport Village3
Northville Village0
Norwich1
Nunda Town and Village0
Ocean Beach Village2
Ogden Town6
Ogdensburg2
Old Brookville Village2
Old Westbury Village1
Olean10
Olive Town1
Oneida9
Oneonta City4
Orangetown Town8
Orchard Park Town5
Oriskany Village0
Ossining Village6
Oswego City16
Owego Village5
Oxford Village0
Oyster Bay Cove Village1
Palmyra Village0
Peekskill8
Pelham Manor Village13
Pelham Village4
Penn Yan Village0
Perry Village1
Phoenix Village1
Piermont Village0
Pine Plains Town0
Plattekill Town4
Plattsburgh City3
Pleasantville Village2
Port Byron Village0
Port Chester Village18
Port Dickinson Village2
Port Jervis2
Port Washington1
Potsdam Village0
Poughkeepsie28
Poughkeepsie Town6
Pound Ridge Town1
Pulaski Village1
Quogue Village2
Ramapo Town34
Red Hook Village0
Rensselaer City5
Rhinebeck Village0
Rochester664
Rockville Centre Village8
Rome28
Rosendale Town0
Rotterdam Town23
Rouses Point Village0
Rye4
Rye Brook Village45
Sackets Harbor Village0
Sag Harbor Village0
Salamanca5
Sands Point Village0
Saranac Lake Village1
Saratoga Springs32
Saugerties Town6
Scarsdale Village3
Schenectady197
Schodack Town1
Schoharie Village0
Scotia Village5
Seneca Falls Town5
Shandaken Town0
Shawangunk Town3
Shelter Island Town0
Sherburne Village0
Sherrill1
Shortsville Village0
Sidney Village2
Skaneateles Village0
Sleepy Hollow Village1
Sodus Point Village0
Sodus Village0
Solvay Village49
South Glens Falls Village4
South Nyack Village0
Southampton Town48
Southampton Village3
Southold Town5
Spring Valley Village13
St. Johnsville Village1
Stillwater Town0
Stockport Town0
Stony Point Town5
Suffern Village3
Syracuse340
Tarrytown Village1
Ticonderoga Town0
Tonawanda4
Tonawanda Town38
Troy90
Trumansburg Village0
Tuckahoe Village5
Tupper Lake Village3
Ulster Town7
Utica79
Vernon Village0
Vestal Town7
Walden Village3
Wallkill Town21
Walton Village1
Wappingers Falls Village0
Warsaw Village0
Warwick Town6
Washingtonville Village1
Waterford Town and Village43
Waterloo Village2
Watertown24
Watervliet11
Watkins Glen Village0
Waverly Village0
Wayland Village0
Webb Town0
Webster Town and Village12
Weedsport Village0
Wellsville Village3
West Carthage Village1
West Seneca Town15
Westfield Village1
Westhampton Beach Village0
White Plains24
Whitesboro Village0
Whitestown Town0
Windham Town0
Woodbury Town4
Woodridge Village0
Woodstock Town0
Yonkers250
Yorktown Town4
Yorkville Village0
Youngstown Village1
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

Not surprisingly, the most populated cities, such as New York City and Buffalo, were among the places where the most car thefts occurred. The prevalence of these incidents emphasizes the need to maintain comprehensive coverage to reimburse you for theft or vandalism.

How many road fatalities occur in New York?

Through crash data from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), we’ll explore which parts of New York are the most hazardous to drive around.

We’ll also explore some of the obvious and overlooked risks of the road, including weather and light conditions, speeding, and alcohol impairment. Sadly, a harsh result of these dangers are crashes that lead to deaths. We’ll look at those statistics, too.

First up, we’ll discover which Empire State highway is the deadliest.

Most Fatal Highway in New York

According to Geotab, over the past decade, 156 fatal crashes occurred along Interstate 87 (I-87), which spans from New York City to Montreal, Quebec, in Canada. The many deadly crashes have resulted in a fatal crash rate of 0.3, based on NHTSA and Federal Highway Administration data. These statistics highlight the need to drive safely there and wherever you are on the road.

The news report below features one of the many crashes that have happened along I-87:

Fatal Crashes by Weather Condition and Light Condition

Rain, snow, and ice can cause dangerous road conditions. However, darkness or daylight can also factor into the hazards. Let’s see how many fatal accidents happened in different weather and light conditions in New York.

Weather ConditionDaylightDark, but LightedDarkDawn or DuskOther / Unknown
Normal409238128361
Rain34281440
Snow/Sleet125400
Other20600
Unknown42312
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

Regardless of conventional wisdom, many of the deaths reported occurred in normal daylight conditions.

Fatalities (All Crashes) by County

We’ve covered the conditions that are likely to lead to crashes. Now, let’s look at where they tend to happen. Here’s how many fatal crashes occurred in each Empire State county.

County20132014201520162017
Albany1025222419
Allegany52452
Bronx5235404940
Broome131115189
Cattaraugus1147511
Cayuga748118
Chautauqua111010139
Chemung731155
Chenango94656
Clinton86394
Columbia968811
Cortland96645
Delaware96827
Dutchess3022262019
Erie5747445043
Essex18233
Franklin16633
Fulton57606
Genesee857514
Greene1231076
Hamilton20010
Herkimer674810
Jefferson1281294
Kings8778695356
Lewis64435
Livingston19376
Madison87936
Monroe3743334545
Montgomery73555
Nassau8381958078
New York4539284838
Niagara2718181715
Oneida2115122218
Onondaga3025332734
Ontario11161698
Orange3536283235
Orleans740411
Oswego2220191716
Otsego54746
Putnam47957
Queens9986786159
Rensselaer1110989
Richmond1212261914
Rockland1717151118
Saratoga1811181918
Schenectady461079
Schoharie24222
Schuyler31233
Seneca55745
St. Lawrence199111010
Steuben12127103
Suffolk145123168139121
Sullivan14131396
Tioga15373
Tompkins8813108
Ulster2412161423
Warren69226
Washington881083
Wayne101013129
Westchester5227513732
Wyoming25735
Yates34210
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

From 2013 to 2017, Suffolk and Nassau Counties consistently had the highest number of fatal crashes in the state. This kind of goes with the territory, as they’re also among the New York counties with the biggest population.

Traffic Fatalities

These figures reveal how many traffic deaths happened in rural versus urban areas of New York.

Details2008200920102011201220132014201520162017
Rural622582571534618630390455463472
Urban616576630637562572651681578527
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

Despite the remoteness of rural areas, the number of crash deaths between them and urban areas was almost even from 2008 to 2017.

Fatalities by Person Type

Whether you’re a passenger in a car, a pedestrian, or a bicyclist, you’re prone to death or injury from a crash. These are the fatalities by the type of vehicle and transportation used in New York.

Vehicle Type20132014201520162017
Passenger car423375368330339
Light truck – utility939011391119
Light truck – pickup5949497047
Light truck – van4126413333
Light truck – other00101
Large truck1614151113
Bus03401
Motorcyclists170148163136145
Pedestrian336264311307242
Bicyclist and other cyclist4046363946
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

Many of the deaths involved passenger car occupants. However, several pedestrian and motorcyclist fatalities also occurred. These figures serve to remind us to keep aware of our surroundings and seek ways to protect ourselves — through proper clothing, equipment, or procedures — in case of a crash.

Fatalities by Crash Type

Now, let’s look at the types of crashes that are most likely to lead to deaths.

Crash Type20132014201520162017
Single vehicle784674709660602
Involving a large truck11898126106121
Involving a rollover160144160144127
Involving a roadway departure580509513471450
Involving an intersection (or intersection-related)467377419385373
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

During the five-year timeframe, most of the crashes involved single vehicles and roadway departures.

Five-year Trend for the Top 10 Counties

These are the numbers of fatalities in the most populated New York counties from 2013 to 2017.

County20132014201520162017
Bronx5235404940
Erie5747445043
Kings8778695356
Monroe3743334545
Nassau8381958078
New York4539284838
Onondaga3025332734
Orange3536283235
Queens9986786159
Suffolk145123168139121
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

Suffolk County had the highest number of fatalities, followed by Nassau and Queens County. New York, Orange, and Onondaga Counties experienced the fewest fatalities out of the top 10, at an average of 30 to 40 yearly.

Fatalities Involving Speeding by County

Speed is among the many factors involved in crash deaths. Which counties had the most and least casualties from speeding?

County20132014201520162017
Albany17735
Allegany20030
Bronx1213101112
Broome14544
Cattaraugus32201
Cayuga11323
Chautauqua43330
Chemung10711
Chenango72131
Clinton13242
Columbia32114
Cortland14212
Delaware32404
Dutchess1771285
Erie1912121711
Essex13011
Franklin13202
Fulton12202
Genesee02612
Greene42223
Hamilton00010
Herkimer43252
Jefferson63431
Kings3118151113
Lewis42423
Livingston12010
Madison31114
Monroe138121815
Montgomery01132
Nassau1432282620
New York66616
Niagara106693
Oneida1052108
Onondaga91091013
Ontario43932
Orange1112111512
Orleans32002
Oswego1310797
Otsego21342
Putnam03312
Queens2922291918
Rensselaer51222
Richmond31865
Rockland78464
Saratoga669111
Schenectady00801
Schoharie01121
Schuyler10110
Seneca13012
St. Lawrence74223
Steuben54220
Suffolk3632334441
Sullivan75932
Tioga01121
Tompkins34123
Ulster44528
Warren13102
Washington31332
Wayne34262
Westchester1012181016
Wyoming13112
Yates01110
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

Though it’s a concern no matter where you are, Suffolk and Nassau Counties had the highest speeding-related accident deaths. Yates, Albany, and Livingston were among those with the fewest.

Fatalities in Crashes Involving an Alcohol-impaired Driver by County

Another major contributor to crashes in New York is alcohol consumption. We’ve all heard the warnings not to drink and drive, but regardless, some people still don’t heed them. These statistics remind us of the consequences of that risky behavior.

County20132014201520162017
Albany28954
Allegany00121
Bronx161281215
Broome56684
Cattaraugus42124
Cayuga21262
Chautauqua25351
Chemung20111
Chenango42112
Clinton31211
Columbia12234
Cortland02204
Delaware20502
Dutchess98972
Erie1413131216
Essex02020
Franklin13111
Fulton21103
Genesee32113
Greene60321
Hamilton20000
Herkimer43222
Jefferson54541
Kings2717141415
Lewis31223
Livingston03212
Madison23311
Monroe151391115
Montgomery41011
Nassau2422271820
New York985810
Niagara115443
Oneida97598
Onondaga1359109
Ontario35623
Orange13114147
Orleans20012
Oswego785106
Otsego21232
Putnam12513
Queens2820221921
Rensselaer32323
Richmond34625
Rockland67424
Saratoga36846
Schenectady01512
Schoharie01110
Schuyler10011
Seneca21422
St. Lawrence73424
Steuben25011
Suffolk4539514237
Sullivan26121
Tioga01232
Tompkins24223
Ulster83347
Warren33101
Washington52322
Wayne45343
Westchester1110141211
Wyoming12112
Yates22010
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

Suffolk and Queens Counties were among those with the highest alcohol-related fatalities.

Teen Drinking and Driving

Teens, sadly, have also been known to take the wheel while they’re intoxicated. Here’s data about underage drinking trends in the Empire State.

DUI Arrests (Under 18 years old)DUI Arrests (Under 18 years old) Total Per Million PeopleRank
11327.0346
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

Fortunately, New York is among the states with the fewest alcohol-impaired fatalities for those under age 21, ranking 46th out of 50 states. Nationally, according to Responsibility.org, the average is 1.2 deaths per 100,000 people.

Together with safe driving, drug and alcohol education is a crucial step in raising awareness of the risks of substance abuse on and off the road. Mothers Against Drunk Driving and other organizations have been especially vocal in helping victims and fighting to prevent people from getting behind the wheel while under the influence.

EMS Response Time

One of the most anticipated arrivals on an accident scene is that of emergency medical services (EMS). Below are their response times for accidents in rural and urban New York areas.

DetailsTime of Crash to EMS
Notification
EMS Notification to
EMS Arrival
EMS Arrival at Scene
to Hospital Arrival
Time of Crash to Hospital
Arrival
Total Fatal Crashes
Rural 3 minutes11 minutes40 minutes50 minutes427
Urban2 minutes5 minutes28 minutes33 minutes506
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

Response times in rural parts of New York, unfortunately, were three times higher than those in cities and suburbs. The delays may be due to difficulties traveling to and from remote areas.

What is transportation like in New York?

New York is one of the most highly populated states, so access to adequate transportation is essential. In this section, we’ll offer statistics from Data USA that show how much car ownership, commute times, and certain forms of transportation play a role in New Yorkers’ lives.

In the end, we’ll cover a constant problem: traffic congestion in the Empire State. Let’s get rolling.

Car Ownership

In New York state, 30 percent of drivers own two cars. Given that residents in major metropolitan areas such as New York City use public transportation, the ratio is 10 percent less than the nationwide average.

Commute Time

Traffic levels are a major factor in the time drivers take to reach their destinations. As you might expect, often because of traffic congestion, New Yorkers face longer commutes than the U.S average. By how much?

The average New Yorkers’ commute is 32.2 minutes one way, which is nearly seven minutes longer than the typical U.S. driver’s time of 25.5 minutes. On top of that, about 6 percent of New Yorkers have a super commute of 90 minutes or more. That’s also more than double the nationwide average.

Commuter Transportation

New Yorkers prefer certain types of transportation over others for their commutes.

Just over 50 percent of residents drive alone, but that number pales in comparison to the U.S. average of 75 percent. Part of that is because more New Yorkers — 28 percent — take public transportation. The number of public transit passengers also happens to be almost six times higher than the national average.

Traffic Congestion

It’s no mystery that traffic congestion is a problem in major New York cities. Here’s how Inrix’s Traffic Scorecard ranks the cities:

City2018 World RankHours Lost in CongestionCost of Congestion (Per Driver)
New York City, NY40133 $1,859
Buffalo, NY15172 $1,009
Get Your Rates Quote Now
Compare RatesStart Now →

New York City is one of the worst spots for traffic, ranking 40th in the world, while Buffalo placed a distant second in the state. Congestion in both cities costs commuters over $1,000 yearly in transportation-related costs, such as gas. So, if you live in those cities, add extra time — and as necessary, pad your budget — for your commute.

By contrast, the TomTom Traffic Index rates NYC 42nd worldwide for the worst traffic congestion. The congestion level on highways and non-highways is 36 percent. That percentage increases during peak commute times — 55 percent in the morning and 69 percent in the evening.

In morning traffic, commuters spend an extra 17 minutes in their cars. That time increases in the evening to 21 minutes.

We’ve reached the end of this comprehensive car insurance guide. Did you learn everything you needed to know? We hope you learned something useful.

And if you’re ready to start comparison shopping for car insurance, enter your ZIP code in our free tool below.

References:

  1. https://discovernys.com/
  2. https://www.britannica.com/place/New-York-state
  3. https://www.consumerreports.org
  4. https://www.thehartford.com/aarp/car-insurance/new-york/state-driving
  5. https://www.dfs.ny.gov/
  6. https://www.naic.org
  7. https://www.allstate.com/drive-wise.aspx
  8. https://www.quadinfo.com/
  9. https://www.jdpower.com/business/press-releases/2019-us-auto-insurance-study
  10. https://naic-cms.org/
  11. https://www.experian.com/blogs/ask-experian/state-of-credit/
  12. http://www.carwindshields.info/states
  13. https://www.aipso.com/Plan-Sites/New-York
  14. https://www.iii.org/article/background-on-insurance-fraud
  15. https://www.nyccriminallawyer.com
  16. http://codes.lp.findlaw.com/
  17. https://ag.ny.gov
  18. https://www.ncleg.net
  19. https://www.myimprov.com/defensive-driving/new-york/ny-traffic-law/
  20. https://www.legendvw.com/weird-driving-laws-on-long-island-and-in-new-york-state/
  21. https://www.dhs.gov
  22. https://dmv.ny.gov
  23. https://www.drivinglaws.org/resources/new-york-s-traffic-violation-point-system.html
  24. https://www.cohenjaffe.com/blog/understanding-new-yorks-comparative-fault-rule/
  25. https://newyork.cbslocal.com/2019/06/18/new-york-seat-belt-back-seat-law/
  26. https://www.trafficlawyer.com/new-york-traffic-ticket-blog/new-york-now-requires-rear-facing-child-safety-seats-in-motor-vehicles
  27. https://drivinglaws.aaa.com/tag/seat-belts/
  28. https://www.responsibility.org/get-the-facts/state-map/state/new-york/
  29. https://www.mpp.org/states/new-york/
  30. https://www.cnn.com/2020/01/09/business/new-york-cannabis-legalization-2020-cuomo/index.html
  31. https://cdan.nhtsa.gov
  32. https://www.geotab.com/the-most-dangerous-highways-in-america/
  33. https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/
  34. https://datausa.io/profile/geo/new-york-ny
  35. http://inrix.com/scorecard/
  36. https://www.tomtom.com/en_gb/trafficindex/list?citySize=ALL&continent=NA&country=US